(404) 266-0082

2809 Peachtree Rd NE
Atlanta, GA 30305 33.8317 -84.385

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Garden Hills, Northside, Northside

Reviews & Ratings for Fellini's Pizza

4.5 Star Rating: Recommended

62 reviews

What users are saying:

Write a review
Reviews from:
4 Star Rating: Recommended

01/27/09

great pizza

by rhphillips at Citysearch

I don't really eat alot of pizza but when i do... this is the place i go. you ca always rely on getting a good calzone or slice.

  • Pros: good variety, tasty pizza, decent cost
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

11/11/08

Fellini's Is Fun & Fabulous

by ciaojan at Citysearch

Once a week I drive past a Fellini's (sorry guys at Roswell & Weiuca - who are also nice) to get to this one!

The atmosphere is fun, music upbeat but not blasting (good for conversation) and the PIZZA is GRRREAT!

Staff is friendly (even though they are usually very busy!) Lindsey, Brooke, Brittany & Danny are just some of the great servers......and a shout out to the guys making the pies too - good work!

  • Pros: Great Pizza / Friendly Staff
  • Cons: Parking!
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/12/08

Great Little Pizza Place

by ahayden at Citysearch

It was the end of a very long day and was getting ready to head home but had missed breakfast and lunch. Only living in Buckhead for a short time i wasnt all that familiar with the area so the limo driver suggested this pizza place. I said sure so we drove by to check it out. It didn't seem all that busy so we parked around back and went in. Wasn't sure what to order so the cashier suggested the "special". Given i was so tired and the place was kinda empty, we just decided to eat there. As someone who loves pizza, i must say it was great!!! Sitting there in the late afternoon having a beer and pizza watching the rain come down, chilling out and listening to the music was a nice end to my hectic day. I can't say how the service or atmosphere would be when they're busy but on this particular lazy rainy day, everything was just perfect. Can't way to go back again ...

  • Pros: Super great pizza. Nice little afternoon lunch spot.
  • Cons: Only a few parking spots in front, mostly must park in back. Inside sign says not to leave valuables in car , something to keep in mind.
1 Star Rating: Poor

09/20/08

Avoid like the plague

by kmabellw at Citysearch

My husband and I recently moved to Atlanta and every time we drove by Fellini's we saw throngs of people eating and/or waiting to eat. Intrigued we finally had a chance to go last night and we were horribly disappointed.

The pizza was pretty tasteless (we ordered a vegetarian) and the dough, even though it was a thin-crust, was undercooked to the point of being chewy. I wouldn't call us picky eaters, but this stuff wasn't even palatable. The waitstaff was kind enough to put our pie back in the oven until it was truly done, but by then we were so under-impressed it didn't really get any better.

I can say that their ingredients did, in fact, appear to be fresh, but the pizza itself was way overrated. The atmosphere is fun, so I'm guessing that's why it gets so many high reviews.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

06/09/08

I Love this place!!!!!

by meesh0202 at Citysearch

I have been to this location Numerous times and every single time I go I have received great service. Its a very relaxed and casual atmosphere. I Love the fact that it stays open late because you can go for a late night snack after hanging out and of course get good food. Now I cant say the food has ALWAYS been great but for the most part the atmosphere and the convenience has outweighed any negatives. The only negative thing I can say about the place is pertaining to the one or two times I did not feel my pizza was of the best taste. I felt it may have been a little old and reheated. It may have been a little harder than usual if you know what I mean. Anyways, I have had more good experiences than bad and will DEFINITELY be there again.

  • Pros: Parking, Service, Convenience
  • Cons: None
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

05/13/08

Best Pizza in the South

by nysgal at Citysearch

I am born and raised in Buffalo, NY- and we have some of the greatest pizza in the Country! When I first moved here, I was determined to find a good pizza place and after many bad meanls I found Felini's! Although most of the time we do take out I do enjoy sitting out on the patio and drinking an ice cold beer with a fresh slice!! Whenever I have visitors in town- this is the spot to go!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

11/24/07

Service with a sneer, cheap beer, decently -priced pizza with a flavor above all said

by thundersroar at Citysearch

the location on Howell Mill has THE BEST BATHROOM EVER!! clean, with a re-furbished Zsumpfelt duo-sink and 30's Neiner-churner is amazing beyond belief(men's bathroom only, I believe)!

  • Pros: They finally added ham
  • Cons: All Fellini's locales have absurd parking lots.
4 Star Rating: Recommended

07/07/07

Good pizza outside of Chicago or NY

by aaront31 at Citysearch

For Atlanta, you expect comfort food, BBQ, things like that, so on a business trip to ATL once I asked a co-worker who lived there for a recommendation on a place to grab some Pizza. Now, I'm pretty picky, but this place has very good pie. Not great, mind you, but hey, it's hard to get really great Pizza outside of Chicago or NY, so for Atlanta, this is going to be your best bet out there!

  • Pros: Good pizza for Atlanta
  • Cons: It's pizza in Atlanta, so you can only expect so much...
4 Star Rating: Recommended

06/03/07

Yum!

by vavi at Citysearch

We've heard mixed reviews about Fel's pizza, but we decided to give it a try, so far.. so good ! we like the pizzas, nice toppings, always fresh and the service, very friendly!

  • Pros: Fresh ingrdients, good service
  • Cons: Parking can sometimes be a challenge at some locations
2 Star Rating: Below Average

12/07/06

Fredrico Would Not Be Happy!

by jaymaygm at Citysearch

Being a long time fan of the now defunct Garden Hills Cinema next door, Fellini's was always a good choice before or after one of the Foreign Films, that drew us cinephiles. And one of our favorite Italian directors was Fredrico Fellini. Hence, Fellini's pizza was born. Great little place in those earlier days. The Garden Hills is now gone, and the quality and taste of Fellini's, has followed suit. Bring back Sophia Loren, and maybe Fellini, will follow.

  • Pros: Nice Walking Neighborhood Destination! Below Average Pizza!
  • Cons: Parking could be a problem, if driving! Service, Pizza!

Showing 1-10 of 55 reviews

Lists In Atlanta

Advertisement
Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Fellini's Pizza

Recent Reviews In Atlanta

2 Star Rating: Below Average

Loop Pizza Grill

3537 Chamblee Tucker Rd, Atlanta, GA

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Grand China Restaurant

2975 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA

3 Star Rating: Average

La Tavola- Virgina Highlands

992 Virginia Ave, Atlanta, GA

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Harry's Pizza & Subs

2150 Powers Ferry Rd SE, Atlanta, GA

Advertisement