Romeo's New York Pizza

(678) 514-1111

9700 Medlock Bridge Rd ste 168
John's Creek, GA 30097 34.017203 -84.19033

Get Map & Directions »

Hours:

Sun-Thu 11:30am-10pm

Fri-Sat 11:30am-11:30pm

Last updated 2.15.11

Category:

Restaurants

Cuisine:

Pizza

ambiance
100.0% positive
  1. “The food is well prepared and plentiful, the atmosphere is good.”
  2. “The atmosphere is clean, warm and inviting.”
  3. “The crust actually had taste, the sauce was not straight out of a can, the service was great and the decor was cool.”
dessert
100.0% positive
  1. “Romeo's uses quality ingredients (which is key in making a great pie)”
  2. “Romeo's uses the highest quality incredients and the sauce and the way they cook the crust until it's crispy makes for a delicious pizza pie.”
  3. “By the pie or by the slice their pizza is awesome as is their signature salad.”
drinks
100.0% positive
  1. “If you're looking for yummy, authentic NY style pizza this place is the best in North Atlanta bar none.”
food quality
98.57000350952148% positive
  1. “I"m a picky pizza guy as I'm from NYC and this pizza is amazing.”
  2. “Romeo's uses the highest quality incredients and the sauce and the way they cook the crust until it's crispy makes for a delicious pizza pie.”
  3. “Great pizza at a reasonable price.”
  4. “The salads are always fresh and served with their family dressing, which is superb.”
  5. “So, as i was saying; i had just about given up on eating pizza while in Ga. and along comes a authentic NY Pizza spot that i can actually sit there and eat slice after slice after slice and still want more.”
  6. “Our FAVORITE pizza place!”
  7. “it's because it was palatable pizza but then again not all the time.”
  8. “Their salads are amazing and their wings are better than the wings at most wings places.”
  9. “Romeo's makes a great tasting authentic NY Pizza, with fresh ingredients.”
  10. “What is about that crust that makes the whole pizza so amazing?”
  11. “Growing up on the mainline near Philadelphia I know good pizza.”
  12. “Service was fast, pizza was good and it was extremely convenient.”
  13. “If you're looking for yummy, authentic NY style pizza this place is the best in North Atlanta bar none.”
  14. “If you like chicken wings, well they serve those too, and they are pretty tasty.”
  15. “The crust actually had taste, the sauce was not straight out of a can, the service was great and the decor was cool.”
  16. “have been waiting for a great New York style pizza place in Johns Creek and its finally here!”
  17. “This place has the best N.Y. style pizza I've ever tasted, even the crust is delectable.”
  18. “If you're in the mood for New York pizza, Romeo's tops 'em all - truly a delightful dining experience for the whole family.”
  19. “The variety of pizza's and the awesome salads with homemade dressing.”
  20. “The Philly cheese steak is fantastic and fillig.”
  21. “The food is well prepared and plentiful, the atmosphere is good.”
  22. “Great pizza”
  23. “Finding a decent NY pizza in this area can be difficult.”
  24. “The owners aren't sharing the secret, but they sure do know how to make some great pizza.”
  25. “The service is fast, and the pizza is the most delicious you will ever taste.”
  26. “We grew up eating some of the best pizza in the world.”
  27. “By the pie or by the slice their pizza is awesome as is their signature salad.”
  28. “Don't miss the great salads and sandwiches, too.”
  29. “The slices are huge and the taste is extremely authentic.”
  30. “Not only can you get great pizza; you can also get great wings.”
  31. “Really, really good pizza”
  32. “The ingredients are fresh, the portions are big, the taste is authentic, and they are even open late.”
  33. “This is pizza at its best, and the most friendly owners you have ever met!”
  34. “Romeo's Ny pizza is the best pizza in the world.”
  35. “If you appreciate really good pizza I hope you will try Romeo's at least once, I have a feeling it won't be your last time stopping in for a bite to eat.”
menu variety
100.0% positive
  1. “The variety of pizza's and the awesome salads with homemade dressing.”
overall
100.0% positive
  1. “have been waiting for a great New York style pizza place in Johns Creek and its finally here!”
service
100.0% positive
  1. “The crust actually had taste, the sauce was not straight out of a can, the service was great and the decor was cool.”
  2. “This is pizza at its best, and the most friendly owners you have ever met!”
  3. “The service is fast, and the pizza is the most delicious you will ever taste.”
value
85.71000099182129% positive
  1. “love their excellent salads, it's not the bagged cheap stuff.”
  2. “The ingredients are fresh, the portions are big, the taste is authentic, and they are even open late.”
  3. “Plentiful great quality ingrediants at a more than a fair price.”
  4. “Prices are a good value, I go there at least once a week.”
  5. “Sure beat the overpriced popcorn I thought I was going to end up with.”
  6. “The slices are huge and the taste is extremely authentic.”
  7. “Great pizza at a reasonable price.”
1 Star Rating: Poor

03/02/12

Romeo's 139 S. Clayton Street Lawrenceville, Ga 30046

by Terry Cates

Last night a party of four of us decided to go out and try this new pizza joint we had heard so much about in Johns Creek. Upon arrival everything went fine. We placed or orders and went to our table to wait. In the mean time one of the females in the group went to the rest room and came back and said both mens ans ladies restrooms were out of order. We tried flushing the toliets and true to the sign said out of order. We approached the manager to question him and we we were asked "who are we to questions his business." From there it went down hill. I questioned how the employees washed their hands after each usage and was told the had to run to McDomalds. I was then tolddue to the fact that "He" Was my worse nightmare. Other people were hearing this converseation and steadily heading for the door.

The police were called by myself to find out if there was antthing they could do about closing the doors of an insanitery place but was told that was up to the the health department. So if licking pee and other bodily matters from employees you don'y know I strongly suggest this place but if you like decent health places to eat I would stay far away.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

09/05/10

great place for a snack

by BklynT

I always drop by Romeo's before catching a movie. A pizza slice always hits the spot. They serve the yummiest slices and the service is always fast.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

08/25/10

great pizza place

by rishaadams

I love the fact that Romeo's pizzas are so fresh and yummy. I make it a point to stop by for a slice before going to the movies. Sometimes, my friends and I hang out here afterwards too.

4 Star Rating: Recommended

08/25/10

Best NY Style Pizza

by dalex420

Man just had some of this pizza yesterday and it was not only some of the best ny style but best pizza ive ever had.Not only made fresh but fresh toppings and you can only eat two peices with garlic bread.Good service and not to mention right next to the movie theater.Perfect for movie and dinner night out with the lady.Deff going back!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

07/15/10

Best NY pizza in ATL!

by CSMobileUser4

My husband and I are from NYC and this pizza reminds us of home. We love it!

The Details on Romeo's New York Pizza

Place Categories:

  • great whole pizza
  • amazing excellent salads
  • fast service
  • authentic ny style pizza
  • warm atmosphere
  • great new york style pizza place
  • great dining experience
  • fresh ingredients
  • great ny pizza
  • delicious pizza pie
  • most friendly owners
  • huge slice
  • like chicken wings
  • authentic taste
  • fantastic philly cheese steak
  • great everything
  • delightful dining
  • overpriced popcorn
  • good value
  • not disappoint romeo
  • delectable crust
  • crispy makes
  • big portions
  • not great sandwiches
  • not great salads
Advertisement

Recent Reviews In Johns Creek

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Dynasty Chinese Restaurant

10955 Jones Bridge Rd Ste 104, Alpharetta, GA

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Kozmo Gastro Pub

11890 Douglas Rd, Alpharetta, GA

Advertisement