New York Prime
Atlanta, GA 30326-1118
Phone: (404) 846-0644
- Price:
- $$$$
- Hours:
- Sun-Thu 5pm-10pm, Fri-Sat 5pm-11pm
Editorial Review for New York Prime – by Philip Malkus
The Scene
Ensconced in a hidden space across from Lenox Square, New York Prime holds its own commendably among the Buckhead steakhouse conglomeration. The traditional man's man look is what you've come to expect from a temple of beef, and it's all here: wood paneling, brass railings, and a square bar in the center of the room. Servers are polished and polite.
The Food
An enormous, ancient lobster paraded around the dining room in a little red wagon is not as enticing as the management might hope, which is fine since the glorious steaks are reason enough to dine here. Go for classics like New York strip and filet mignon, both of which are properly aged and succulently juicy. Gigantic oysters Rockefeller are textbook specimens, covered in creamy spinach, Parmesan and bacon. For a decadent ending, try a piece of delicate banana cream pie.
Editorial content is independent of paid advertisers. Any expenses are paid for by Citysearch.
Insider Tips
Know Before You GoThe restaurant can be tricky to find. From 400, get off at the Lenox exit heading toward Peachtree and watch carefully for signs leading to Monarch Drive. The restaurant is in the base of an office building where Monarch ends.
What to DrinkThe extensive wine list--with dependably enjoyable choices in every price tier--can be largely attributed to co-owner Jerry Greenbaum, who also owns the two Green's liquor stores in Atlanta, both of which have excellent fine wine selections.
User Reviews for New York Prime
05/22/2007 Posted by jaymaygm
I have been by this restaurant, dozens of times since it has been open. Last night, a business associate was staying next door at the Ritz Carlton Buckhead. My friend insisted I join him here for dinner. As to why he did not ask me where to dine in Buckhead for steak, is beyond me. He is from NYC. Buckhead has many excellent steakhouse fine dining destinations. I was hesitant, but gladly went along. The first thing I noticed, was the smell of strong cigar smoke. I'm not a smoker, and well you know the rest. The menu read nicely, but at these prices, it had better be darn good. I opted for one of those 3-4 lobsters, I usually order across the street, at a well-known NYC steakhouse. The presentation was terrible, Why did my server forget the drawn butter? And my friend's steak was overcooked. I just smiled, and thought about all the other really great steakhouses in Buckhead. Our waiters attitude, was that of someone serving a salesman at an auto convention. I dine out several times a week, and I will never come back here, even if my friend is from New York!
Pros: It Was Near My Friend's Hotel!
Cons: Over-Hyped, Over-Priced Buckhead Steakhouse! Service?
01/05/2007 Posted by deehendricks
I picked out New York Prime for our office dinner. There were 18 of us and we all agreed that it was one of the best meals we had ever eaten. They served us two large trays of appetizers that were delicious. It had oysters, lumb crab, crab claws and shrimp. Then along with our steaks and side dishes we were all stuffed. Everything was cooked to perfection. I will recommend this resturant to everyone. Not only was the food and atmosphere perfect but the custmer service was at the top of the chart. We had two waiters the entire time and we never wanted for anything. Charles was one of them and I sorry but the young ladies name I can't remember something like Kalen. We will be back. A great time had by all.
Pros: Food and customers service
Cons: Smokey bar area
0 out of 1 people found this review helpful
Users Like You Also Viewed
Bone's Restaurant
3130 Piedmont Road
Atlanta, GA 30305
Chops
70 West Paces Ferry
Atlanta, GA 30305
