Olde Mill Steakhouse

10/15/09

WORST PLACE EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

by twaters0326 at Citysearch

THIS IS THE WORST PLACE TO EAT EVER! THE SERVER HAD A BAD ATTITUDE THE MANAGERS ARE RUDE, MY FOOD WAS HORRIBLE I WENT IN ON A TUESDAY DAY AND IT TOOK 45 MINS TO GET MY FOOD AND THEN IT WAS COLD AND THE PLATE WAS SO HOT I COULDN'T TOUCH IT! DO NOT GO HERE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

• Pros: BAD SERVICE BAD FOOD BAD ALL AROUND
• Cons: EVERYTHING

11/24/06

Tilapia is always good

by atlpetey at Citysearch

We used to love going to Olde Mill, because it was consistently good and never crowded. But we had a bad experience with the steak being cooked wrong, very wrong, so we haven't been back. It's too expensive to be messing up like that. We may give it another try soon. The tilapia is always good.

09/22/06

Rude Manager - food not cooked as ordered

by jsteele4392 at Citysearch

food is inconsistent. Had salmon that was way undercooked. several menu items listed but not available. Recently, steak was well done when medium was ordered. Manager was extremely rude. When we mentioned that the steak was cooked incorrectly, he stated that we could choose to order a replacement or finish the steak - his exact words were "either way, it's on me". We chose to order a replacement and had it to go, since it was a weekday lunch, and had to get back to work. When we received our check, it included the price of the steak. The manager stated that since we ordered a replacement we had to pay. He said he couldnt remenber what he said 10 minutes before, that everyone is a regular when I mentioned that we were regulars there. Then he proceeded to say that he's been scammed twice earlier, and insinuated that we were trying to scam him. He ended removing the item off the check, but totally left a bad taste with us. We will never go there again at least while he's managing!

• Pros: None
• Cons: Food is not cooked to order, Manager was extremely rude.